How NOT to lose the plot when submitting your book
Recently literary agent Juliet Mushens suggested in a Tweet that it’s a good idea to submit to eight to ten agents at a time rather than blanket submitting. Brilliant advice, I reckon. If your book’s got some kind of magic to it, you might just get some agent feedback. Even if the book gets rejected, you could still come away more clued-up about what’s not right with it, bruised ego aside. You might then choose to rework it before submitting to other agents.
A few months ago, I got a request for the full manuscript of my second book. Ultimately the agent turned it down saying she didn’t find the characters likeable enough and she wasn’t sure what was driving the story. I’ve stopped sending it out and am halfway through a rewrite. I think the characters are more sympathetic now, with meatier back stories; I might just have a better book on my hands.
That brings me back to my first book. I had some encouraging agent interest in it two months ago and ended up rewriting it. The book is stronger now and I’ve sent the first three chapters to several agents. So here’s how to hold onto your sanity while waiting for a reply.
1. Don’t refresh your email account every five minutes.
Turn it off. Turn off social media too. Do not allow yourself to look at the Twitter accounts of the eight agents on your list. God, she’s reading Goddamn Marlon James when she should be reading my MS…. Look away. Log off. Go and do something less boring instead.
2. Don’t be tempted to send out to more than ten agents at a time.
Remember, you might just learn something. So you’ve written the whole thing in patois and the agent who loved your concept absolutely hated the Gads instead of Gods, the me sandals instead of my sandals. Okay, admittedly there might be those of you who love that kind of thang (sic), but if more than one agent says it doesn’t work, it could be time to take notice. If after the first few submissions, you learn two things about how to improve your book, you’ll be well pleased you didn’t do multiple submissions.
3. Do not delete the rejection emails.
Your lips may bulge with that silent F, so let them, but do not let your fingers smash that delete box. It’s very useful to keep a log of who’s rejected you. That doesn’t mean you can’t contact them again when the book is better, or when you’ve penned your second masterpiece. And just because you’ve got a rejection from one person at a big agency doesn’t mean to say someone else at that agency won’t fall in love with your writing. Also, think about how much fun it’s going to be counting up all those rejection letters when you’re finally published. Yeah, put that in your pipe and smoke it, Mrs/Mr ‘I’m going to pass….’
4. When an agent asks to see the full manuscript, don’t stand in front of the mirror practising what you’re going to say if she/he offers you representation.
‘I’d just like to thank my husband for his attention to apostrophes, my friend Jill who was there from the start….’ Waste of time! Chances are you might have a long wait for representation, so instead of risking your family banging on the bathroom door – ‘Is everything alright in there?’ – just get back to writing, or reading, or thinking up new ideas. Preferably all three.
5. Do not put your writing on hold.
If anything write more. Discarding all of the above, this is one thing I have managed to do. I’ve always got a short story on the go. Just write something, anything, write rubbish then rework it, edit it, perfect it. For me, short stories silence the self-doubt. I love them. They’re a rejection letter quick fix. So keeeeeeep writing!
6. Do not burn your book.
So you’ve now got 30 rejections in the bag, but don’t start carping. ‘That’s it, I’m finished.’ Last year an agent who I met at a literary event talked about how a novelist’s first novel often becomes her second or third published novel. And since I know a couple of best-selling authors, I can vouch for that. Keep searching for ideas, maybe even start book two. Keep trying. Things can only get better, right?
5 thoughts on “How to Stay Sane When Submitting Your Novel”
Great post. I agree with you 100%.
Currently sending out book No 1 and have had eight rejection letters in six weeks. Some said it wasn’t for them but not to be discouraged and two didn’t ‘love’ the voice. Not sure how I can change/improve this because that is pretty subjective, right?
Still waiting to hear back from a few more but am well into the planning and researching of book No 2.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes, it is so subjective. I’m not really falling into the book I’m reading at the moment, and it was nominated for the Booker Prize a few years back. Standard rejection letters hurt, but some of your feedback sounds promising.Hang in there. Very best of luck!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Really good advice here – I think the same applies when waiting at the next stage, for publishers, too! It’s so hard to keep writing, but it’s the thing that will keep the madness from setting in ;). Also, I’ve found that not all agents will give more than generic feedback (not for us, didn’t love it etc), so when they do, it’s a real bonus and should definitely be listened to :). Thanks for posting this :).
LikeLiked by 1 person
Great advice – an agent requested my whole manuscript after reading my first 3 chapters and then commented ‘I wish I’d just left it at the memory of the start, it’s terrible after that.’ Ouch – but she gave me feedback and 3 re-writes later, I’m getting published. I think she was an exception but they are out there. And the short stories tip is a really good one.
I bet that hurt! But yes, it’s such a relief to have some honesty. Great news. Congrats, Catherine.